Why do my Reddit posts keep getting removed?
Often a silent AutoMod removal: your post looks live to you but vanishes for everyone else. The cause is usually one of six things: a karma gate, an account-age gate, a banned keyword, a link in a text-only sub, a blocked domain, or missing flair.
Launched my tool today, here is what I learned
Illustrative example, what you see
Launched my tool today, here is what I learned
Illustrative example, what the community sees
- 01Quick answer (TL;DR)
- 02Symptom, cause, and fix table
- 03Silent AutoMod removals explained
- 04Who removed it: mods, AutoMod, or Reddit
- 05Karma and account-age gates
- 06Banned phrases that trigger AutoMod
- 07Removed vs. shadowbanned?
- 08How to tell if AutoMod removed your post
- 09What to do right after a removal
- 108 common mistakes
- 11Pre-post checklist
- 12FAQ
Why was my Reddit post removed? The short answer
A Reddit post gets removed by a subreddit moderator, by AutoModerator running that sub's rules, or by Reddit's own spam filters. The usual triggers are a karma or account-age gate, missing flair, a link or blocked domain, a banned phrase, or breaking the self-promotion rule. Check for a removal message, then reread the sub's rules, then ask the mods.
Many silent Reddit post removals come from AutoModerator, a bot each subreddit's mod team configures independently. The six most common triggers are: (1) your account karma is below the sub's minimum threshold (often 50 to 2,000 combined), (2) your account is younger than the sub's age gate (7 to 90 days), (3) your post title or body contains a banned phrase like "DM me," "discount code," or "check my profile," (4) you included a link in a sub that only allows text posts, (5) your domain is on the sub's blocklist, or (6) you skipped required post flair. Many subs send no notification for these, so the post just disappears. The fix for each is different, and the diagnosis table below maps every symptom to a cause and a fix.

Symptom, cause, and fix for every removal type
Find what matches your experience, then follow the fix column. If you see your post vanishing within seconds, start at row one.
| Symptom | Most likely cause | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Post vanishes within seconds of submitting | AutoMod karma or account-age gate | Build comment karma to the sub's threshold (often 50-500+). Check sidebar rules for the exact number. |
| Post visible to you when logged in, invisible to others | Silent AutoMod removal (most common) OR spam filter | Open an incognito window and search for your post. If it is gone, AutoMod removed it. Message the moderators politely. |
| Post shows for a few minutes then disappears | Human mod review triggered by AutoMod flag | A mod reviewed and removed it. Re-read the subreddit rules. Your content or format likely violated a specific rule. |
| "Your post has been removed" notification received | Rule violation caught by human mod | The removal reason is usually in the notification. Appeal via modmail if you genuinely believe it was an error. |
| Post removed in a sub that normally allows your topic | Missing required flair, link in a text-only sub, or banned keyword in title | Add the required flair, remove the URL from the post body, or rephrase the title without the flagged phrase. |
| Post removed only from certain subreddits | Your domain is on that sub's blocklist OR account karma is below the per-sub threshold | Message the sub's mod team to ask if your domain is blocked. If karma, build it via comments over 2-4 weeks. |
| Every post removed across all subreddits | Account shadowban or global spam flag | Check your shadowban status at reddit.com/user/[username] while logged out. If page shows "page not found," you are shadowbanned. |
| Removal note mentions self-promotion, spam, or advertising | The sub's self-promotion rule, or too much of your activity linking to your own site | A common rule of thumb (often called the 10% or 9:1 guideline) is that roughly 10% or less of what you post should be your own material, and many subs set their own stricter limits. Comment and contribute first, then use the sub's promo thread if it has one. |
| Post removed with no mod message and no AutoMod reply | Sub has quiet AutoMod set to remove-without-comment | Some subs set it up this way on purpose. Contact the mod team via modmail asking why. Frame it as a genuine question, not a complaint. |
If you cannot find your symptom in the table above, the most productive next step is to message the subreddit's moderators via modmail. Ask specifically: "Can you tell me what rule my post violated?" Many mods reply within a day or two and can point you to the exact AutoMod trigger.
Check the subreddit before you post there
Type a subreddit to see how active it is and when its members post, free, no signup. Then read its rules for the gates and filters that apply.
How silent AutoMod removal works
- 1You submit the postIt goes to AutoModerator first, not the public feed.
- 2AutoMod matches a ruleKarma, account age, keyword, link, domain, or flair. Any single match is enough.
- 3Status flips to removedOften with no message to you, because many mod teams choose not to notify.
- 4You still see it, others do notYour profile shows the post normally. In incognito, the URL is empty.
How a silent removal plays out
What "removed" looks like from the poster's side
Your post appears normally when you view your own profile. The URL works for you. Comments you leave on the post are visible to you. But every other logged-out user or logged-in user who is not a mod sees nothing at that URL. This is Reddit's standard removal behavior, not a bug. The post is in a "removed" state only mods can see in the mod queue.
What AutoMod checks
AutoMod evaluates every post against rules defined by the subreddit's mod team. Common checks include: account karma (combined, post, comment, or sub-specific), account age in days, keywords in the title or body, the post type (link vs. text), whether the domain is on a blocklist, whether flair was selected, and whether the post frequency from that account exceeds a per-sub limit. Any single match can trigger removal, and the rules are cumulative. A post that passes the karma check can still be removed for a keyword match.
Moderators, AutoMod, or Reddit: who removed your post?
Three different things can take a post down, and each needs a different fix. Knowing which one it was saves you from rewriting a post that was never the problem.
Rough guide, the cards below explain each source
AutoModerator (a bot the mods configure)
Applies the sub's written rules: karma and account-age gates, keywords, links, flair, post frequency. It is fast, often within seconds of posting, and some subs have it leave a comment while others stay silent.
Fix: Meet the rule it checks. The sidebar, wiki, and any removal comment usually tell you which one.
A human moderator
Judges what a bot cannot: off-topic posts, low effort, duplicates, promotion that reads as an ad. It can happen minutes or days later, and a note may arrive as a comment, a mod message, or not at all.
Fix: Reread the rules, then send one polite modmail asking what to change.
Reddit's own spam filters
Run sitewide, outside any single sub's rules. They tend to catch new accounts, repeated links, and anything that looks like spam. Moderators can often review a post that was filtered this way and approve it if it was a false positive.
Fix: Ask the mods to check their mod queue. If every post you make vanishes everywhere, check for a shadowban.
The same three sources apply to comments. If your comment vanished instead of a post, the checks and fixes on this page work the same way, and brand-new accounts are filtered in many subs for comments as well as posts. Building comment history helps; the guide to getting karma on Reddit covers how to do it without tripping filters.

Karma thresholds and account-age requirements by community tier
These are rough, community-reported estimates, not official numbers. Typical ranges, so check each sub's sidebar and AutoMod config. "Strict" does not mean large, some 50,000-member subs have tighter gates than 2-million-member subs. Check every sub individually before posting.
Illustrative relative scale built from rough, community-reported ranges. Not official figures
Open communities
AutoMod gates are low or absent. Human mods review flagged posts after the fact.
Mid-tier (conditional promo)
Self-promotion allowed in weekly threads or with explicit value. AutoMod gates active on new posts.
Quality technical communities
Near-zero tolerance for promotional posts. Gates are strict AND human mods review everything that passes AutoMod.
Finance and health communities
Flair is mandatory. Promotional domains are blocklisted. Moderation is active and consistent.
Large general communities
Post type rules are strict (questions only in AskReddit, for example). Off-format posts removed instantly.
Does karma in one sub count for another sub?
It depends on how the subreddit's AutoMod is configured. Most gates check your total combined karma sitewide. But some subreddits, particularly technical ones, check your karma within that specific sub. Accumulating 2,000 karma in gaming subs does nothing for your standing in r/webdev. The safest approach: spend 2-4 weeks commenting substantively in your target sub before attempting a post. See the companion guide on how much karma you need to post on Reddit for per-subreddit breakdowns. If you are short on karma, the how to get karma on Reddit guide has a day-by-day plan for your first week.
Phrases that get your post auto-removed (with alternatives)
AutoMod keyword lists are set per subreddit, but these eight phrases are commonly blocked by subreddit AutoMod configs. Even one of these in your title or post body can silently kill the post.
Use my discount code, limited time, DM me for details
Illustrative example
Safe alternatives to common trigger phrases
Is your post removed, or are you shadowbanned?
These are two very different problems with different fixes. Run through these checks in order to know which one applies to you.
Open the post URL in an incognito window (or log out)
If your post is visible in incognito, it is live, the issue is something else (maybe you are looking at the wrong sub or the post is in a different sort order). If the URL returns "page not found" or shows nothing, go to step 2.
Visit your profile while logged out
Go to reddit.com/user/[yourusername] in an incognito window. If your profile loads normally and shows your comment history, you are NOT shadowbanned. Your posts are being removed at the subreddit level (AutoMod or mod action). Skip to step 4.
If the page returns "page not found" or "this user does not exist," you are shadowbanned at the sitewide level. All your posts and comments are invisible to everyone. Go to step 3.
If you ARE shadowbanned
Submit an appeal to Reddit admins at reddit.com/appeals. The volunteers at r/ShadowBan only check accounts and advise, they are not Reddit admins. Shadowbans are applied for spam-like behavior: posting the same URL to many subs, using VPNs flagged as spam sources, or having multiple accounts that triggered previous bans. You can also check the dedicated guide on how to check if you are shadowbanned on Reddit.
If your post is removed (not shadowbanned)
Check your inbox for a removal reason notification. If there is none, message the subreddit's mod team via modmail: "Hi, my post [title] was removed. Can you tell me what rule was violated so I can fix it?" Many mod teams reply within a day or two. Meanwhile, review the sub's full sidebar rules and the diagnosis table above to identify the likely cause.
- Your profile is visible when logged out
- Other posts from your account are still up
- Only the specific post is gone
- Fix: appeal to sub mods or repost correctly
- Profile returns "page not found" when logged out
- ALL posts and comments are invisible to others
- You appear to post normally but nothing is visible
- Fix: appeal at reddit.com/appeals (r/ShadowBan only checks and advises)

How to confirm AutoMod silently removed your post
There is no dashboard that tells you "AutoMod removed your post." You have to infer it from a short sequence of checks. Here is the fastest path from suspicion to confirmation.
- 1Open the post URL in incognitoCopy your post's URL from your profile. Open a private/incognito browser window (one where you are not logged into Reddit). Paste the URL. If you see the post, it is live. If you see an error or empty page, proceed to the next step.
- 2Check the subreddit's new feedGo to the subreddit directly and sort by "New." Look for your post title. If your post does not appear in the new feed within 10 minutes of submitting but is still in your profile, AutoMod intercepted it before it entered the public queue.
- 3Search for your post by titleUse Reddit's search: "site:reddit.com/r/[subreddit] [your post title]" in Google. A live post often appears in Google results within hours, though that is not guaranteed. No results = the post was not indexed = it was removed before Google's crawler saw it.
- 4Check your notification inboxVisit reddit.com/message/inbox. Look for a message from the subreddit's AutoModerator or a mod. Most subs send no notification for AutoMod removals. If you DO see a removal notice, it will usually state the reason, follow that reason to the relevant section above.
- 5Message the mod teamIf all signs point to a silent removal, send a modmail: "Hi, I submitted a post [title] about [topic] a few hours ago but it does not appear in the new feed. Could you tell me if AutoMod removed it and why?" This is the most reliable way to get a definitive answer.
Modmail script that gets responses
"Hi mods, I submitted a post [title + URL] recently and it does not appear in the sub's new feed. I am not sure if AutoMod flagged something or if I missed a rule. Could you take a look and let me know what I can fix? I want to contribute correctly to the community. Thanks." Short, non-confrontational, and specific, mod teams tend to respond better to this format than to complaints.
What to do right after your Reddit post is removed
The first hour decides whether this is a quick fix or a ban. Do these in order.
- Read any removal message or mod comment first, then reread the sub's full rules
- Confirm it is the post and not the account (incognito check, then your logged-out profile)
- Send one short, polite modmail with the post link and ask what to change
- Fix the specific cause: flair, link, phrase, karma, or format
- Rewrite for that community's tone before you try again
- Repost the identical post right away, it usually gets removed again and can look like spam
- Argue with moderators or send repeated modmails
- Post the same content to several other subs to see what sticks
- Make a new account to get around the removal, which counts as ban evasion
- Delete your history or panic-edit old posts before you know the cause
Rewriting is the step most people skip. A post that follows the rules can still fall flat or get pulled because the tone is off for that sub. If you post in several communities, a writer like MediaFast drafts each post in the target sub's tone. If the sub is simply the wrong fit, use the subreddit finder to pick a better home for it.
8 mistakes that get posts removed on Reddit
These cover the vast majority of removal cases. Most people who ask "why does Reddit keep removing my posts" are hitting at least two of these simultaneously.
My new tool, same post I shared in four other subs today
Illustrative example
Most of these can be avoided before you submit. Read the sub's rules, and use SubredditAnalyzer to check when the community is active and which subs fit your post. The companion guide on how to promote on Reddit covers the full warming and posting playbook.
Run this checklist before every Reddit post
If every item below checks out, your post has a strong chance of clearing AutoMod. One "no" is enough to get removed silently.

Post where your community is active, at the hours it is awake
SubredditAnalyzer shows any subreddit's hourly posting heatmap, activity health, related communities and side-by-side comparisons, so you pick the right sub and the right time. Your first subreddit is free.
Analyze a subreddit freeStart free. Upgrade for less than one boosted post.
- View 1 subreddit at a time
- Browse tracked subreddits
- Track 5 custom subreddits
- Add any subreddit you want
- Track 15 custom subreddits
- Add any subreddit you want
- Track 30 custom subreddits
- Add any subreddit you want
Reddit post removal FAQ
Answers to the most common questions about why posts get removed and what to do.
Why does Reddit remove my posts without telling me?+−
Reddit's AutoModerator is configured by each subreddit's mod team to remove posts silently, meaning no notification to the poster. This is a deliberate choice: mods find it reduces argument and ban-evasion attempts. The post looks live to you when logged in but is invisible to everyone else. To check, open an incognito browser and search for your username and post title.
How much karma do I need to post without getting removed?+−
It depends on the subreddit. Low-barrier communities like r/SideProject accept accounts with 50+ comment karma. Mid-tier communities like r/Entrepreneur typically require 200-500+. Technical communities like r/programming or r/webdev can require 1,000+ and may enforce a combined karma+account-age gate. Some subs require karma earned specifically within that sub, not just sitewide totals.
How old does my Reddit account need to be to post?+−
Most communities that enforce age gates require at least 7-30 days. Strict subreddits often require 30-90 days. The account age gate is usually combined with a karma gate, so both must be met simultaneously. A 60-day account with no karma still gets auto-removed in many quality subs.
What is the difference between a removed post and a shadowbanned post?+−
A removed post is visible only in your own profile when logged in; it appears normally to you but not to others. A shadowban is a sitewide status where your entire account's posts and comments are invisible to everyone except you, you appear to post normally but nothing reaches anyone. To check for shadowban, visit reddit.com/user/[yourusername] while logged out. 'Page not found' means you are shadowbanned.
Can I get my removed post reinstated?+−
Yes, via modmail. Open the subreddit, click 'Message the Moderators,' and politely explain why you believe the removal was in error. Include a link to the removed post. Do not be argumentative, mods receive hundreds of requests. If your post genuinely violated a rule, accept it and repost without the violation. Repeated appeals for clearly-rule-violating posts can result in a ban.
Why was my Reddit post removed?+−
A post is removed by a subreddit moderator, by AutoModerator running that sub's rules, or by Reddit's sitewide spam filters. The usual triggers are a karma or account-age gate, missing flair, a link or blocked domain, a banned phrase, or breaking the self-promotion rule. Check for a removal message, reread the rules, then ask the mods.
How do I find out why my Reddit post was removed?+−
Look for a comment or message explaining the removal, open the post in an incognito window to confirm it is hidden, and reread the sub's rules for karma, age, flair, link, and keyword requirements. If nothing explains it, send one polite modmail with the post link and ask what to change. Many mod teams answer genuine questions.
Why was my Reddit comment removed?+−
The same three sources apply: a moderator, AutoModerator, or Reddit's spam filters. Common reasons are a karma or account-age gate, a link, a banned phrase, or breaking a sub rule such as self-promotion. New accounts are filtered most often. Check the sub's rules, then ask the mods through modmail if no reason is given.
Should I repost a removed Reddit post?+−
Not until you know the cause. Reposting the same content usually gets removed again, and repeated attempts can look like spam and lead to a ban from the sub. Fix the cause, reread the rules, and if you are unsure, ask the mods first. Using a new account to repost is ban evasion and makes things worse.
Why does my post get removed in some subreddits but not others?+−
Each subreddit has its own AutoMod configuration, karma thresholds, domain blocklists, and flair requirements. A post about a software tool might be fine in r/SideProject but auto-removed in r/webdev because the latter has stricter self-promotion rules. There is no universal Reddit policy that covers all subs equally, you have to check the sidebar rules of each individual community before posting.
More free Reddit tools and guides
Pick the next stop. Each page is built for one specific question, with live data where it makes sense.